Best Dentists in Lancaster, OH: Your 2025 Complete Guide

If you’re searching for the best dentists near me in Lancaster, Ohio, you’re in luck! Just like our city has grown from its historic roots along Zane’s Trace to become a vibrant part of the Columbus metro area, our top-rated dental care options have expanded too. Whether you live downtown near the Georgian Museum or out by River Valley Mall, we’ll help you find the perfect dentist for your specific needs.

How DenScore Identifies Lancaster’s Top-Rated Dentists

We take the guesswork out of finding the best dentists in Lancaster, OH by carefully evaluating dental practices based on what matters most to patients. Our ratings consider clinical qualifications, patient satisfaction scores, and appointment availability. Think of us as your dental-savvy friends who’ve done all the research for you! We thoroughly vet every dentist on our platform to ensure they meet our high standards for quality dental care.

Some of the dentists listed below may pay for a sponsored listing or agree to put a DenScore badge on their website in order to be recognized, but they are held to the same strict quality control guidelines as every other provider on this list. Whether you choose a dentist from this list or not, we always recommend doing your own research beforehand. For more information, please refer to our Terms of Service.

Rank Name Dental Office Address City State Zip Code Phone Number Website
1 MADISEN ELY DENTAL ASSOCIATES OF LANCASTER INC 115 W FAIR AVE LANCASTER OH 43130 740-654-3660 https://www.dentalassociateslancaster.com/
2 JENNIFER LAPE GENTLE DENTAL CARE LLC 208 N COLUMBUS ST LANCASTER OH 43130 740-653-8671 https://www.dentistlancasteroh.com/
3 JESSICA MCDAVID FRIENDLY DENTAL CARE 611 N BROAD ST LANCASTER OH 43130 740-687-6105 http://friendlydental.com/
4 BARRIE ZWEIER LOGAN FAMILY DENTAL 31490 CHIEFTAIN DR STE B LOGAN OH 43138 740-380-1333 https://www.wilsonfamilydental.net/
5 JEFFREY WILSON JEFFREY A WILSON DDS INC 700 N COLUMBUS ST LANCASTER OH 43130 740-654-7217 https://www.wilsonfamilydental.net/
6 RICHARD LIGHTSEY FAIRFIELD FAMILY DENTAL 2019 SCHORRWAY DR LANCASTER OH 43130 740-653-1031 http://fairfieldfamilydentaloh.com/
7 BRANDON CANFIELD COMFORT DENTAL LANCASTER 1601 N MEMORIAL DR LANCASTER OH 43130 740-521-4142 https://comfortdental.com/office/oh-lancaster/
8 JULIE MESSERLY JULIE D MESSERLY DDS LLC 127 W 6TH AVE LANCASTER OH 43130 740-687-4484 http://www.messerlydental.com/
9 MARK NEFF MARK E NEFF DDS 1532 SHERIDAN DR LANCASTER OH 43130 740-653-8100 http://neffdds.com/
10 KERRI BENJAMIN-BRANDT KERRI BENJAMIN-BRANDT DDS INC 1506 AMHERST PL SW LANCASTER OH 43130 740-654-2010 http://www.drbenjaminbrandtdds.com/
11 JAMES FRILLING RIVER VALLEY DENTAL JAMES FRILLING DDS LLC 1579 TIKI LN LANCASTER OH 43130 740-653-8706 http://www.lancasterdentist.net/

*sponsored listing

Maximizing Dental Insurance Benefits in Lancaster

Absolutely! Having the right dental insurance can make quality dental care much more affordable. If you’re eligible for Medicaid, your children can receive free dental care, though adult coverage is more limited. For our senior neighbors, while traditional Medicare doesn’t cover dental work, many Medicare Advantage plans offer excellent dental benefits that can help with those bigger procedures we all hope to avoid but sometimes need. It’s important to understand whether you’re seeing an in-network or out-of-network dentist to maximize your benefits.

Smart Ways to Save on Quality Dental Care

Just like planning ahead for the Fairfield County Fair each October, being proactive about your dental health can save you money in the long run. Regular brushing, flossing, and watching your sugar intake are your best defenses against expensive dental problems. Many local dental offices offer membership plans that can make regular care more affordable if you don’t have insurance. And here’s a money-saving tip: dental prices can vary quite a bit, so don’t be shy about calling different offices to compare costs for specific procedures. We’re all about helping you find quality care that won’t break the bank!

How do I know if I’m getting the right dental treatment?

Whether you have a tooth that needs to be fixed, a gum problem, or concerns about your smile, there are likely multiple ways to treat your condition. DenScore’s free online dental tool will provide you with information so you can ask your dentist the right questions and get the high-quality dental care you deserve.

Key Takeaways

  • Lancaster offers numerous top-rated dental care options for residents throughout Fairfield County
  • DenScore’s comprehensive rating system helps identify the best dentists near you
  • Multiple insurance and payment options make affordable dental care accessible
  • Preventive care and dental membership plans can help reduce long-term costs
  • Local dental practices offer competitive pricing for quality dental services