Best Dentists in Reynoldsburg, OH (2025): Your Complete Guide

Whether you’re new to Reynoldsburg or just looking for a change, finding the right dentist for your needs can feel overwhelming. With our growing community of over 41,000 residents in Reynoldsburg, Ohio, there are quite a few top-rated dental care providers to choose from. But don’t worry – just like picking the perfect tomato at our famous Tomato Festival, we’ll help you select an affordable dentist that’s just right for you!

How DenScore Identifies Top-Rated Dentists in Reynoldsburg

We take the guesswork out of finding the best dentists in Reynoldsburg, OH by carefully evaluating dental practices based on what matters most to patients. Our comprehensive rating system considers clinical qualifications, patient satisfaction scores, and practical factors like scheduling flexibility. Think of us as your dental matchmakers – we do the research so you can focus on getting the quality dental care you need.

Some of the dentists listed below may pay for a sponsored listing or agree to put a DenScore badge on their website in order to be recognized, but they are held to the same strict quality control guidelines as every other provider on this list. Whether you choose a dentist from this list or not, we always recommend doing your own research beforehand. For more information, please refer to our Terms of Service.

Rank Name Dental Office Address City State Zip Code Phone Number Website
1 KEITH YOHMAN FRENCHRUN FAMILY DENTAL CARLY LOCSEY DDS LLC 1344 LANCASTER AVE REYNOLDSBURG OH 43068 614-866-1234 https://www.frenchrundental.com/
2 CHRISTINE MARQUARD DR CHRISTINE MARQUARD DDS LLC 655 COMMERCE DR PICKERINGTON OH 43147 614-833-0805 https://www.dentistpickerington.com/
3 CHARLES CONKEY STONERIDGE DENTAL CARE 925 N HAMILTON RD STE 200 GAHANNA OH 43230 614-476-6696 https://www.stoneridgedentalcare.com/
4 ANTHONY DINAPOLI ANTHONY DINAPOLI DDS LLC 3158 E BROAD ST COLUMBUS OH 43209 614-231-6872 https://www.dentalhubbexley.com/
5 MAURINA BROOKS HOT SMILE LLC 60 S JAMES RD COLUMBUS OH 43213 614-235-5560 http://www.hotsmiledental.com/
6 MICHAEL FLEITZ MICHAEL P FLEITZ DDS INC 426 BEECHER RD GAHANNA OH 43230 614-939-4800 http://www.drfleitz.com/
7 AFSHAN SULTAN OHIO FAMILY DENTISTRY LLC DR AFSHAN SULTAN 1021 HILL RD N PICKERINGTON OH 43147 614-694-0320 http://ohiofamilydentistry.com/
8 ANKIT PATEL ANKIT PATEL DDS LLC 7395 E MAIN ST REYNOLDSBURG OH 43068 614-860-0065 https://www.blacklickcreekdental.com/
9 ZIAD AL HENNAWI STELLER DENTISTRY LLC 6810 E MAIN ST STE 200 REYNOLDSBURG OH 43068 614-974-2900 http://reynoldsburgdentist.com/
10 GERDALINDE GATMAITAN DR GERDALINDE GATMAITAN DDS LLC 3040 E MAIN ST COLUMBUS OH 43209 614-231-4527 http://gerdafamilydental.com/
11 JASON KAHAN EASTPOINT DENTAL 7334 E BROAD ST STE A BLACKLICK OH 43004 614-755-2275 https://www.eastpointdental.com/
12 ERIC ZIDEL DANIEL L ZIDEL DDS INC 4575 WINCHESTER PIKE COLUMBUS OH 43232 614-837-2080 http://zideldentalgroup.com/
13 ARASSA JOSEPH STONECREEK DENTAL CARE 11295 STONECREEK DR PICKERINGTON OH 43147 614-864-3196 https://helpmysmile.com/pickerington
14 AKLILU AMEHA PHILLIP KATZ DDS 156 W COLUMBUS ST PICKERINGTON OH 43147 614-837-4506 http://www.stateoftheartsmiles.com/
15 KYLE HICKMAN HAVENS FAMILY DENTAL LLC 1582 N WAGGONER RD STE B BLACKLICK OH 43004 614-762-2737 https://www.havensfamilydental.com/
16 PRASHANTHI VADHI VADHI OHIO FAMILY DENTAL CENTER 6023 E MAIN ST COLUMBUS OH 43213 614-864-6000 https://www.vadhiohiofamilydental.com/
17 GIANNI DIMICHAELANGELO DIMICHAELANGELO FAMILY DENTISTRY INC 15 E HUBBARD AVE COLUMBUS OH 43215 614-924-0406 https://healthysmiles.com/short-north/
18 JEFFREY HANIN JEFFREY HANIN DDS INC 3370 E BROAD ST COLUMBUS OH 43213 614-237-2529 http://www.hanindentistry.com/
19 MICHAEL CONNOR CROSS CREEKS DENTAL 1555 CROSS CREEKS BLVD PICKERINGTON OH 43147 614-866-2895 http://www.crosscreeksdental.com/
20 JOHN MARSHALL MARSHALL DENTAL LLC 5180 E MAIN ST STE D COLUMBUS OH 43213 614-836-1033 http://www.marshall-dental.com/
21 CHAD OMAN HUGUENIN DENTAL LLC 699 HILL RD N PICKERINGTON OH 43147 614-837-1440 https://www.hugueninfamilydentaloh.com/
22 DANIELLE DEY MODERN ELEVATIONS DENTISTRY 10991 NATIONAL RD SW # B ETNA OH 43062 740-785-7444 http://www.modernelevations.com/
23 RYAN NAYLOR REYNOLDSBURG DENTAL CENTER 6504 E MAIN ST REYNOLDSBURG OH 43068 614-866-4186 http://reynoldsburgdentalcenter.com/
24 HARSH SHAH REYNOLDSBURG DENTAL ASSOCIATES 1338 ROSEHILL RD REYNOLDSBURG OH 43068 614-694-0363 https://www.facebook.com/reynoldsburgdentalassociates
25 JOSEPH PAPP REYNOLDSBURG J & J DDS LLC 7589 E MAIN ST STE B REYNOLDSBURG OH 43068 614-866-5518 http://www.reynoldsburgfamilydental.com/
26 AARON BARKLEY DIVINE FAMILY DENTISTRY 6465 E BOARD ST STE C COLUMBUS OH 43213 614-762-2206 http://ohiofamilydentistry.com/
27 MATTHEW SNIPES TRURO DENTAL DR MATTHEW SNIPES LLC 145 REYNOLDSBURG NEW ALBANY RD STE 200 BLACKLICK OH 43004 614-866-3368 http://www.mycapstonedental.com/
28 JOHN DAUGHERTY STONEGATE DENTAL 6490 E MAIN ST STE D REYNOLDSBURG OH 43068 614-866-3301 http://www.stonegatedental.net/
29 MARCEL DANEAULT BRICE DENTAL GROUP 1600 BRICE RD STE 2 REYNOLDSBURG OH 43068 614-866-5966 https://bricedentalgroup.com/
30 MAIA SAAD VIOLET FAMILY DENTAL 151 CLINT DR STE 300 PICKERINGTON OH 43147 614-575-1155 http://www.violetfamilydental.com/

*sponsored listing

Understanding Dental Insurance Coverage in Reynoldsburg

Choosing the right dental insurance plan can definitely help make treatment more affordable, but navigating coverage options can be tricky. If you qualify for Medicaid, your children can receive free dental care, though adult coverage is more limited. For our senior neighbors, while basic Medicare doesn’t cover dental work, many Medicare Advantage plans offer excellent dental benefits that can help with costly procedures at local Reynoldsburg dental offices.

Smart Ways to Save on Quality Dental Care

Just like taking a relaxing walk through Blacklick Woods helps prevent stress, good preventive dental care helps prevent expensive problems. Maintain excellent oral hygiene, watch your sugar intake, and avoid tobacco products. Staying with in-network dentists usually saves money. No insurance? No problem! Many local dental offices offer membership plans that make care more budget-friendly. And since prices can vary significantly, we always recommend calling a few offices to compare costs for specific procedures if you’re paying out of pocket.

How do I know if I’m getting the right dental treatment?

Whether you have a tooth that needs to be fixed, a gum problem, or concerns about your smile, there are likely multiple ways to treat your condition. DenScore’s free online dental tool will provide you with information so you can ask your dentist the right questions and get the high-quality dental care you deserve.

Key Takeaways

  • Reynoldsburg offers numerous highly-rated dental practices for its 41,000+ residents
  • DenScore’s rating system helps identify the best dentists based on qualifications and patient satisfaction
  • Multiple insurance options and payment plans make dental care more affordable
  • Preventive care and in-network providers help minimize out-of-pocket costs
  • Local dental offices offer flexible payment options for uninsured patients