FINDING THE BEST DENTIST

Best Dentist Near Me in Amherst, OH

Discover top-rated dentists in Amherst who are nearby, aligned with your needs, and committed to delivering a great experience.

Board-certified orthodontist offering braces near you in St. Louis
Leading orthodontist in St. Louis, Missouri
Best Orthodontist in St. Louis, MO

Last Reviewed: April 26, 2026

About the Author

Dr. Kyle Gernhofer

DenScore Dental Expert

Dr. Kyle Gernhofer is a clinician and business leader determined to make dental navigation a leading force in healthcare. Through his work in private practice, military dentistry, and dental consulting, he has guided DenScore in creating a solution that delivers greater value to patients, providers, insurers, and employers.

Top 3 Dentists in Amherst

Get to know our Top 3 Amherst dental practices and discover why so many patients trust them with their smiles

Douglas D. Means DMD

Address: 1710 Cooper Foster Park Rd # A, Lorain, OH 44053

Phone: (440) 282-3642

East Amherst Dental Center

Address: 6471 Transit Rd, East Amherst, NY 14051

Phone: (716) 689-6300

Team Leatherman Care Dentistry

Address: 6100 S Broadway, Lorain, OH 44053

Phone: (440) 233-8521

Have you got a Dental Practice?

Get in touch to start growing it.

Have you got a Dental Practice?

Get in touch to start growing it.

Our Ranking Methodology

DenScore is a proprietary AI ranking algorithm that surfaces the dentists most likely to provide high-quality care, earn trust, and deliver a strong patient experience. By analyzing thousands of online reviews, the model identifies patterns linked to clinical skill, communication, and satisfaction. It also incorporates affordability and accessibility data – including insurance participation, office hours, location, hygienist staffing, and other practice-level features – because each plays a role in determining whether timely, affordable, high-quality care is achievable. The framework is also designed to integrate claims-based dental metrics so treatment outcomes and clinical philosophy are more accurately reflected. Together, these inputs help patients find the best dentists and make smarter, more informed decisions for better outcomes.

Other Top Dentists in Amherst

While these dentists didn’t make our Top 3, we still rate them highly and believe they may be worth considering.

Amherst Dental Associates

Address: 255 S Main St, Amherst, OH 44001

Phone: 440-988-5711

Buffalo General Dentistry | Implant, Sedation & Cosmetic

Address: 4955 N Bailey Ave #110, Amherst, NY 14226

Phone: (716) 836-1620

Vecchio and Schafer DDS

Address: 1288 Abbe Rd N C, Elyria, OH 44035

Phone: 440-365-9580

Amherst Neighborhood Dentistry

Address: 2266 Kresge Dr, Amherst, OH 44001

Phone: (440) 960-0090

Matthew J. Elbert, D.D.S. Amherst Dental Professionals

Address: 1495 Cooper Foster Park Rd, Amherst, OH 44001

Phone: 440-282-5501

Amherst Dentistry

Address: 8588 Transit Rd, East Amherst, NY 14051

Phone: (716) 636-1399

Vecchio & Schafer DDS (formerly Henderson & Henderson DDS)

Address: 1288 Abbe Rd N, Elyria, OH 44035

Phone: 440-365-7645

Amherst Dental Group

Address: 650 Main St, Amherst, MA 01002

Phone: (413) 253-9582

Frequently Asked Questions

Start by verifying state licensure through the Ohio State Dental Board and confirm the dentist’s DDS or DMD credentials. In Amherst, OH, many practices offer new patient exams that should include comprehensive X-rays and oral cancer screenings — always ask exactly what’s covered. Check online reviews for patterns: multiple mentions of rushed appointments, unclear billing, or pushy treatment plans are red flags. Conversely, modern digital X-ray equipment, itemized estimates before work begins, and clear explanations of treatment options signal quality care. For more tips for finding the best dentist, refer to our guide. In-network vs out-of-network decisions directly impact costs; an in-network practice typically means lower out-of-pocket expenses but verify your specific plan. Look up the best local dentists in your area to compare options and find a trusted provider.

Most dental insurance plans follow the 100/80/50 rule — 100% coverage for preventive cleanings, 80% for basic fillings, and 50% for major work like crowns or bridges. In Amherst, OH, East Amherst Dental Center is actually located in New York, not Ohio, so verify its network participation if you’re in Ohio. For Amherst residents, in-network dentists accept your plan’s negotiated fees, while out-of-network dentists often charge more. Annual maximums typically cap between $1,000 and $2,000; once you exceed that, you pay the full cost. Consider a dental savings plan as an alternative — it offers discounts without waiting periods. You can also check our list of best dentists in Pataskala, OH for more options. Also, Original Medicare doesn’t cover routine dental, so seniors may need a Medicare Advantage plan or separate coverage. Explore Ohio dental insurance options to find a plan that fits your budget.

Yes, dental schools like those affiliated with Case Western Reserve University or other nearby programs can reduce costs by 50–70% because supervised students perform the work. For Amherst, OH residents, Federally Qualified Health Centers (FQHCs) in Lorain County offer sliding‑scale fees based on income. Always request an itemized estimate and insurance pre‑authorization before any major procedure to avoid surprise bills. You might also consider highly rated Perrysburg dentists as an alternative. Payment plans through CareCredit or in‑house financing are common at practices like Douglas D. Means DMD in Lorain. Remember, a $200 preventive cleaning can prevent a $2,000 crown later — investing in regular care saves money long‑term.

Always ask for an itemized estimate before agreeing to any procedure — reputable practices like Team Leatherman Care Dentistry in Lorain will provide one upfront. If a recommended treatment exceeds $500, get a second opinion; it’s your right and a sign of ethical care. You can also compare dental insurance in Ohio to check coverage details. Dental anxiety affects about 36% of patients, so ask about sedation options like nitrous oxide or oral sedation. Appointment scarcity is common; many practices book 3–6 weeks out, but some reserve slots for new patients. Good practices explain why a treatment is needed and present alternatives, not just the most expensive option. If you feel pressured, walk away.

DenScore aggregates thousands of verified patient reviews to detect consistent patterns in clinical quality, communication, wait times, and billing transparency across practices. For Amherst, OH listings, we evaluate accessibility factors including insurance acceptance, office hours, location convenience, and whether the practice is actively accepting new patients. DenScore also incorporates claims‑based metrics — anonymized data from insurance submissions — to give a fuller picture of treatment philosophy and outcomes beyond online reputation alone. This methodology helps you identify dentists who deliver consistent, honest care rather than just high star ratings. Our list of trusted dentists in Powell is a great example of this approach. We do not rank on popularity, only on what real experiences reveal. For specific coverage guidance, explore our information on dental insurance in ohio implants.

Popular Searches