Best Dentists in Central Islip, NY (2025): Your Complete Guide

Whether you’re new to Central Islip or have been here since the days of the old psychiatric center, finding the right dentist for your needs can feel overwhelming. With our diverse community of over 34,000 residents, there are plenty of top-rated dental practices to choose from. That’s where we come in! At DenScore, we’re here to help you find the perfect dentist near you, making the process as easy as catching a Ducks game at Bethpage Ballpark.

How DenScore Identifies the Best Dentists in Central Islip, NY

We take the guesswork out of finding a great dentist by evaluating practices based on what really matters – clinical expertise, patient satisfaction, and convenience. Think of us as your dental matchmakers! We look at everything from a dentist’s qualifications and patient reviews to their scheduling flexibility. Just like how Central Islip has transformed itself with new developments over the years, we’re constantly updating our ratings to ensure you have the most current information about the best dentists near you.

Some of the dentists listed below may pay for a sponsored listing or agree to put a DenScore badge on their website in order to be recognized, but they are held to the same strict quality control guidelines as every other provider on this list. Whether you choose a dentist from this list or not, we always recommend doing your own research beforehand. For more information, please refer to our Terms of Service.

Rank Name Dental Office Address City State Zip Code Phone Number Website
1 RAYMOND MASCOLO RAYMOND MASCOLO DDS PC 242 MAIN ST ISLIP NY 11751 631-224-7660 http://www.drmascolo.com/
2 EUGENE AVRASH FAMILY DENTAL CARE LLP 111 SMITHTOWN BYP STE 203 HAUPPAUGE NY 11788 631-265-6262 http://www.hauppaugefamilydental.com/
3 ANDREW HOFFER HARRY Z HOFFER DDS PC 523 TOWNLINE RD STE 13 HAUPPAUGE NY 11788 631-979-7446 http://www.hofferdentalcare.com/
4 RADHA SACHDEVA-MUNK SMITHTOWN DENTAL PC 203 SMITHTOWN BLVD NESCONSET NY 11767 631-724-4220 https://smithtowndentalpc.com/
5 SURESH PATEL SUFFOLK DENTAL SMILES PC 375 E MAIN ST STE 19 BAY SHORE NY 11706 631-665-0165 https://www.advanceddentalcare.net/
6 GRACE FRARACCIO YOUR SMILE DENTAL 353 VETERANS MEMORIAL HWY STE 105 COMMACK NY 11725 631-462-0300 https://yoursmilegroup.com/
7 DAVID BROUGHTON THE SMILIST 228 E MAIN ST EAST ISLIP NY 11730 631-581-8600 https://thesmilist.com/east-islip-dentist/
8 JOHN CAESAR NESCONSET DENTAL ASSOCIATES PC 239 SMITHTOWN BLVD NESCONSET NY 11767 631-724-0094 https://www.bellasmilesnow.com/
9 MICHAEL MAIORINO YOUR SMILE DENTAL OF HAUPPAUGE PLLC 521 ROUTE 111 STE 106 HAUPPAUGE NY 11788 631-361-6605 https://yoursmilegroup.com/
10 ANDREW GEORGAKOPOULOS SACHEM DENTAL GROUP 110 SMITHTOWN BLVD NESCONSET NY 11767 631-382-8585 http://sachemdental.com/locations/nesconset/
11 SIMMY ARORA OASIS DENTAL 70 CARLETON AVE CENTRAL ISLIP NY 11722 631-778-6611 https://www.oasisdentalny.com/
12 MICHAEL VOGELL MICHAEL E VOGELL 110 SMITHTOWN BLVD NESCONSET NY 11767 631-588-8280 http://sachemdental.com/locations/ronkonkoma/
13 YOONIL CHA ROCK DENTAL CARE PC 740 VETERANS HWY STE 304 HAUPPAUGE NY 11788 631-265-2610 https://rockdentalcare.com/
14 ANDREW ANDREOU MK DENTAL CARE 886 W JERICHO TPKE SMITHTOWN NY 11787 631-462-2810 https://rockdentalcare.com/
15 JENNIFER AGLIATO THE SMILIST 269 E MAIN ST BLDG E SMITHTOWN NY 11787 631-352-0642 http://www.thesmilist.com/smithtown-dentist/
16 ARSALAN ASGHAR NOW DENTAL OF SUFFOLK 496 SMITHTOWN BYP STE 300 SMITHTOWN NY 11787 631-360-8000 https://nowdentalofsuffolk.com/
17 STEPHEN VUOLO LYNN PIERRI DDS MS 400 TOWNLINE RD STE 135 HAUPPAUGE NY 11788 631-360-0266 http://destinationdentalusa.com/
18 ROBERT BRODY GREAT EXPRESSIONS DENTAL CENTERS 1601 VETERANS MEMORIAL HWY ISLANDIA NY 11749 631-348-7777 https://www.greatexpressions.com/dental-offices/dentist-in-islandia-new-york/
19 AMIT PATEL GREAT EXPRESSIONS DENTAL CENTERS 1701 SUNRISE HWY SPC C7 BAY SHORE NY 11706 631-666-1440 https://www.greatexpressions.com/dental-offices/dentist-in-bay-shore-new-york-sunrise-highway-space-no-c7/
20 NAYAT BOSTANCI HACIKIAN BRENTWOOD DENTAL CARE PLLC 1814 5TH AVE BAY SHORE NY 11706 631-273-8111 https://brentwooddentalcares.com/
21 CARY GANZ CONCERNED DENTAL CARE OF HAUPPAUGE PLLC 335 TERRY RD SMITHTOWN NY 11787 631-724-0104 https://concerneddentalcare.com/locations/hauppauge/
22 ALLEN MOTOLA HARBOR BAY DENTAL LLC 53 BRENTWOOD RD STE C BAY SHORE NY 11706 631-666-0427 http://harborbaydental.com/specialized/
23 PAUL LEARY SMITHTOWN FAMILY DENTISTRY PLLC 80 MAPLE AVE STE 206 SMITHTOWN NY 11787 631-724-3837 http://smithtownfamilydentistry.com/
24 RICHARD DOMOZYCH ROBERT TEISCH JOSEPH A SIMONETTI AND DOM 1556 ISLIP AVE BRENTWOOD NY 11717 631-234-7979 https://www.simonettianddomozychdental.com/
25 RAQUEL LOPEZ RAQUEL L LOPEZ DDS FAMILY DENTISTRY PC 1247 SUFFOLK AVE STE 2 BRENTWOOD NY 11717 631-434-7156 https://rlfamilydentistry.com/

*sponsored listing

Dental Insurance Options in Central Islip

Absolutely! Choosing the right dental insurance can make quality dental care much more affordable. If you’re eligible for Medicaid, your children can receive free dental care, though adult coverage is more limited. For our senior neighbors, while traditional Medicare doesn’t cover dental work, many Medicare Advantage plans offer great dental benefits that can help manage the cost of more extensive procedures. Understanding whether to choose an in-network or out-of-network dentist can also significantly impact your out-of-pocket costs.

Tips for Affordable Dental Care in Central Islip

The best way to keep dental costs down is prevention – it’s like regular maintenance on your car, but for your smile! Good oral hygiene habits, watching your sugar intake, and avoiding tobacco products will save you money in the long run. Many local dental offices offer membership plans that can make regular care more affordable, especially if you don’t have insurance. And here’s a money-saving tip: prices can vary significantly between practices, so don’t be shy about calling around to compare costs. Just like shopping at different stores along Suffolk Avenue, a little price comparison can lead to big savings!

How do I know if I’m getting the right dental treatment?

Whether you have a tooth that needs to be fixed, a gum problem, or concerns about your smile, there are likely multiple ways to treat your condition. DenScore’s free online dental tool will provide you with information so you can ask your dentist the right questions and get the high-quality dental care you deserve.

Key Takeaways

  • DenScore helps you find top-rated dental care providers in Central Islip, NY
  • We evaluate dentists based on clinical expertise, patient satisfaction, and convenience
  • Various insurance options are available to make dental care more affordable
  • Preventive care and price comparison can help reduce dental costs
  • Local dental practices offer membership plans for uninsured patients

Remember, investing in your dental health today means a brighter, healthier smile tomorrow. We’re here to help you find the best dentists in Central Islip that fit both your needs and your budget.