Best Dentists in Middle Island, NY (2025): Expert Guide to Affordable Dental Care

Looking for top-rated dental care in Middle Island, NY? Whether you’re near Artist Lake or Cathedral Pines, finding the right dentist for your needs doesn’t have to be overwhelming. Our comprehensive guide helps local residents discover quality, affordable dentists in Middle Island while maintaining their oral health and budget.

How DenScore Identifies the Best Dentists Near You in Middle Island

Just like the historic pines that Jonathan Edwards brought to Middle Island, we believe great dental care should stand the test of time. DenScore’s thorough evaluation process helps identify the best dentists near you by analyzing:

  • Clinical qualifications and expertise
  • Patient reviews and satisfaction rates
  • Appointment availability and office hours
  • Educational background and continuing education

Some of the dentists listed below may pay for a sponsored listing or agree to put a DenScore badge on their website in order to be recognized, but they are held to the same strict quality control guidelines as every other provider on this list. Whether you choose a dentist from this list or not, we always recommend doing your own research beforehand. For more information, please refer to our Terms of Service.

Rank Name Dental Office Address City State Zip Code Phone Number Website
1 RAYMOND WOZNY WADING RIVER COMPLETE DENTAL CARE 6278 RTE 25A WDNG RVR SQ WADING RIVER NY 11792 631-929-8709 https://thesmilist.com/wading-river-dentist/
2 ERAN ARVILLI ERAN ARVILLI DDS PC 1636 MONTAUK HWY STE 3 MASTIC NY 11950 631-772-7379 http://drarvilli3ddental.com/
3 MEENA SHAH LAKE GROVE DENTISTRY PC 1014 HAWKINS AVE LAKE GROVE NY 11755 631-467-7878 http://www.lakegrovedentistry.com/
4 EDWARD ZERBO DISTINCTIVE DENTISTRY OF LONG ISLAND 140 TERRYVILLE RD PORT JEFFERSON STATION NY 11776 631-473-3094 http://www.distinctivedentistryoflongisland.com/
5 NICHOLAS GIANNUZZI DENTAL365 SHOREHAM 134 ROUTE 25A SHOREHAM NY 11786 631-821-4110 https://www.godental365.com/location/dentist-shoreham
6 HILSHA CARRION MODERN DENTISTRY OF LONG ISLAND PC 714 MAIN ST PORT JEFFERSON NY 11777 631-473-0582 http://www.limoderndentistry.com/
7 TAMER BARSOM GENTLE DENTAL WADING RIVER 6304 ROUTE 25A WADING RIVER NY 11792 631-929-6833 https://www.puredental.com/wading-river/
8 TAMER BARSOM GENTLE DENTAL MIDDLE ISLAND 225 MIDDLE COUNTRY RD MIDDLE ISLAND NY 11953 631-924-8606 https://www.godental365.com/location/dentist-middle-island
9 KEITH VIBERT PURE DENTAL OF LONG ISLAND PC 5962 ROUTE 25A WADING RIVER NY 11792 631-285-2828 https://www.puredental.com/wading-river/
10 SUZANNE COHEN SHORE LINE FAMILY DENTAL 6282 ROUTE 25A WADING RIVER NY 11792 631-929-6800 http://www.shorelinedentistry.net/
11 SNEHAL SHETH SNEHAL SHETH 2500 NESCONSET HWY BLDG 12D STONY BROOK NY 11790 631-689-3226 http://www.sbcosmeticdentistry.com/
12 YELENA MINDEL SUFFOLK DENTAL CARE PC 3650 ROUTE 112 STE 105 CORAM NY 11727 631-732-3400 https://www.coramdentist.com/about
13 MICHAEL SALKIN THE SMILIST 699 MIDDLE COUNTRY RD MIDDLE ISLAND NY 11953 631-924-8155 https://thesmilist.com/tdc-middle-island-dentist/
14 JAMES HOEG CHARLES R HOEG DMD PC 45 ROUTE 25A STE A1 SHOREHAM NY 11786 631-744-2288 http://shorehamsmiles.com/
15 NICHOLAS NICASTRO NJ NICASTRO DENTAL PC 5225 NESCONSET HWY STE 52 PORT JEFFERSON STATION NY 11776 631-928-2020 https://www.godental365.com/location/dentist-port-jefferson-station
16 ANTONIO CASANOVA SELDEN DENTAL 325 MIDDLE COUNTRY RD SELDEN NY 11784 631-696-6600 https://yoursmilegroup.com/
17 HOMA AMERI ROCKY POINT FAMILY DENTISTRY PC 809 ROUTE 25A ROCKY POINT NY 11778 631-744-3770 https://www.rockypointfamilydentistry.net/
18 FARRA ISAACSON FARRA ISAACSON DDS 1150 PORTION RD STE 15 HOLTSVILLE NY 11742 631-696-3820 http://www.thatsthetooth.com/
19 JIVTESH SINGH A & B DENTAL PC 499 WILLIAM FLOYD PKWY SHIRLEY NY 11967 631-281-1440 https://www.abdentalny.com/
20 GEORGE KANE CORAM SELDEN DENTAL GROUP 280 MIDDLE COUNTRY RD STE K SELDEN NY 11784 631-732-9000 https://www.coramseldendental.com/
21 EDWARD ZERBO SORAL & ZERBO DENTAL ASSOCIATES PLLC 250 PATCHOGUE YAPHANK RD EAST PATCHOGUE NY 11772 631-758-8400 https://www.distinctivedentistryoflongisland.com/
22 BHARATI BEDI BHARATI J BEDI PC DDS 280 GREENBELT PKWY HOLTSVILLE NY 11742 631-472-1832 https://www.holtsvillefamilydentalservices.com/offices.html

*sponsored listing

Maximizing Dental Insurance Benefits in Middle Island

Choosing the right dental insurance plan makes finding affordable dentists near you easier. Here’s what Middle Island residents should know:

  • Medicaid offers free dental care for eligible children
  • Adult Medicaid provides limited but essential coverage
  • Medicare Advantage plans often include comprehensive dental benefits
  • Traditional insurance can significantly reduce out-of-pocket costs

Smart Ways to Save on Top-Rated Dental Care

Just as regular maintenance keeps the greens pristine at Spring Lake Golf Club, preventive dental care is your best investment. Consider these money-saving strategies:

Key Takeaways

  • Middle Island offers numerous highly-rated dental practices for all budgets
  • DenScore’s evaluation system helps identify the most qualified local dentists
  • Insurance and payment plans make quality dental care more accessible
  • Preventive care and price comparison can lead to significant savings
  • Local dental practices offer various options for uninsured patients
  • How do I know if I’m getting the right dental treatment?

    Whether you have a tooth that needs to be fixed, a gum problem, or concerns about your smile, there are likely multiple ways to treat your condition. DenScore’s free online dental tool will provide you with information so you can ask your dentist the right questions and get the high-quality dental care you deserve.