Best Dentists in West Islip, NY (2025): Your Complete Guide to Local Dental Care

Living in a bustling Long Island community like West Islip means you have plenty of dental care options to choose from. Whether you’re closer to Good Samaritan Hospital or enjoying life near the Great South Bay, we at DenScore are here to help you find the right dentist that fits your needs and budget.

How DenScore Identifies Top-Rated Dental Care Providers in West Islip

We know choosing the best dentist can feel as overwhelming as navigating summer traffic on Montauk Highway! That’s why we’ve created a thorough rating system that evaluates West Islip dentists based on what really matters – their clinical qualifications, patient satisfaction, and scheduling convenience. We carefully review each dentist’s credentials and patient feedback to help you find affordable dentists near you that you can trust. Think of us as that knowledgeable friend who always knows where to find the best of everything!

Some of the dentists listed below may pay for a sponsored listing or agree to put a DenScore badge on their website in order to be recognized, but they are held to the same strict quality control guidelines as every other provider on this list. Whether you choose a dentist from this list or not, we always recommend doing your own research beforehand. For more information, please refer to our Terms of Service.

Rank Name Dental Office Address City State Zip Code Phone Number Website
1 JOSEPH SACCO RAYMOND MASCOLO DDS PC 242 MAIN ST ISLIP NY 11751 631-224-7660 http://www.drmascolo.com/
2 NILAY NANAVATI LINDENHURST GENERAL AND FAMILY DENTISTRY 26 W JOHN ST LINDENHURST NY 11757 631-226-4540 http://www.nilaynanavatidds.com/
3 ANIL SISHTA THE SMILIST 796 DEER PARK AVE UNIT 4 NORTH BABYLON NY 11703 631-620-3300 https://www.thesmilist.com/north-babylon-dentist
4 ANUDEEP GREWAL PEARLY PLACE DENTAL 120 BROADWAY, SUITE B AMITYVILLE NY 11701 631-598-2368 https://www.pearlyplacedental.com/
5 STEVEN SPECTOR S SPECTOR 43 MONTAUK HWY LINDENHURST NY 11757 631-226-1900 https://www.pearlyplacedental.com/
6 CHRISTOPHER PROTO CHRISTOPHER PROTO DDS 143 N CARLL AVE STE 1 BABYLON NY 11702 631-669-2330 http://www.protodental.com/
7 THOMAS DONNELLY DRS GARDNER AND DONNELLY 970 SUNRISE HWY WEST BABYLON NY 11704 631-669-8855 http://www.libertyarmsdental.com/
8 FRANK TARANTINO FRANK J TARANTINO DDS PC 4891 MERRICK RD MASSAPEQUA PARK NY 11762 516-308-7121 http://www.drfranktarantino.com/
9 ALEXANDER EINBINDER CATEPILLAR DENTAL 102 ROUTE 109 WEST BABYLON NY 11704 631-619-0010 https://www.gracedentalsmiles.com/
10 ASYA SHOR SHOR DENTAL PC 837 DEER PARK AVE NORTH BABYLON NY 11703 631-587-4545 http://www.northbabylondental.com/
11 MIKE CALDERON MIKE E CALDERON DDS PC 720 MONTAUK HWY WEST ISLIP NY 11795 631-666-1392 http://facelipsteeth.com/
12 PETER KOYS CHARLES M LEO DDS PC 2050 DEER PARK AVE DEER PARK NY 11729 631-586-2600 https://www.lkdentalgroup.com/
13 HENRY FERDMAN HENRY I FERDMAN DDS PC 496 W MAIN ST BABYLON NY 11702 631-669-1878 http://babylondentist.com/
14 ANGELA PITRE ANGELA BAUS PITRE DDS PC 456 UNION BLVD WEST ISLIP NY 11795 631-422-1104 https://comfortdental.dtpcreative.com/
15 KAMRAN SANANDAJI BAY SHORE FAMILY DENTAL 1322 5TH AVE BAY SHORE NY 11706 631-968-5995 https://bayshorefamilydental.com/
16 PREEKITA GUPTA PREETIKA GUPTA DDS PC 1521 STRAIGHT PATH WYANDANCH NY 11798 631-643-3800 http://www.wyandanchdentalcare.com/
17 JEFFREY DELUCCIA NASSAU SHORES FAMILY DENTAL 5404 MERRICK RD MASSAPEQUA NY 11758 516-798-2020 https://bayshorefamilydental.com/
18 ZUHAIR NWAISER SEAPORT DENTAL PLLC 492 W MONTAUK HWY LINDENHURST NY 11757 631-991-8700 http://www.seaportdentaloffice.com/
19 SEFIK YAVUZ MYA DENTAL ARTS PC 1117 DEER PARK AVE NORTH BABYLON NY 11703 631-595-2400 http://www.myadental.com/our-practice/meet-the-doctor/
20 CHARLES HANDELMAN CHARLES S HANDELMAN DMD PC 1681 DEER PARK AVE DEER PARK NY 11729 631-586-0555 http://cshdmdny.com/
21 MASOOD SYED MASOOD SYED FMLY DNTSTRY PC 652 SUFFOLK AVE BRENTWOOD NY 11717 631-273-5888 https://www.masoodsyeddds.com/
22 JESSICA KRAUSZ RAPHAELSON DENTAL ASSOCIATES LLP 450 GRAND BLVD DEER PARK NY 11729 631-667-4080 http://www.raphaelsondds.com/
23 JAKE SHAPIRO PROHEALTH DENTAL PLLC 11 BAY SHORE RD BAY SHORE NY 11706 631-586-6300 https://www.phdental.com/bay-shore/meet-the-team/
24 HOBIN KANG HOBIN KANG DDS PLLC 266 SUNRISE HWY LINDENHURST NY 11757 631-226-5252 https://www.sperberandportnoydds.com/
25 SUN WON BABYLON DENTAL CARE 785 W MONTAUK HWY WEST BABYLON NY 11704 631-587-7373 http://www.babylondentalcare.com/

*sponsored listing

Understanding Dental Insurance Coverage in West Islip

Dental insurance can definitely make treatment more affordable when you find the right dental insurance plan. If you qualify for Medicaid, your children can receive free dental care, though adult coverage is more limited. For our senior neighbors, while traditional Medicare doesn’t cover dental work, many Medicare Advantage plans offer great dental benefits that can help with costly procedures. We’re happy to help you understand your coverage options.

Smart Ways to Save on Quality Dental Care

The best way to keep dental costs down is prevention – maintaining good oral hygiene habits, watching your sugar intake, and avoiding tobacco products will save you money (and discomfort!) in the long run. If you have insurance, staying with an in-network dentist usually means better savings. No insurance? Don’t worry! Many West Islip dental offices offer membership plans that make care more affordable. And since prices can vary significantly between practices, we recommend calling a few offices to compare costs for specific procedures when paying cash. A little research can lead to big savings!

Remember, investing in your smile today means healthier teeth (and a healthier wallet) tomorrow. We’re here to help you find excellent, affordable dental care right here in West Islip.

How do I know if I’m getting the right dental treatment?

Whether you have a tooth that needs to be fixed, a gum problem, or concerns about your smile, there are likely multiple ways to treat your condition. DenScore’s free online dental tool will provide you with information so you can ask your dentist the right questions and get the high-quality dental care you deserve.

Key Takeaways

  • DenScore thoroughly evaluates West Islip dentists based on qualifications, patient satisfaction, and convenience
  • Multiple insurance options are available, including Medicare Advantage plans with dental coverage
  • Preventive care and staying in-network can help reduce dental costs
  • Many local dental practices offer membership plans for uninsured patients
  • Compare prices between different West Islip dental offices for the best rates