Best Dentists in Port Jefferson, NY (2025): Your Complete Guide to Local Dental Care

Whether you’re new to our charming harbor town or a longtime resident who remembers when the shipyards were still active, finding the right dentist in Port Jefferson and the surrounding area can feel overwhelming. Just like choosing the perfect spot to watch the sunset from Harborfront Park, selecting a dentist is a personal decision that deserves careful consideration. We’re here to help make that choice easier.

How DenScore Identifies Top-Rated Dentists in Port Jefferson

We evaluate dentists using a comprehensive rating system that looks at what matters most to patients. Think of us as your friendly neighborhood dental detectives – we examine everything from clinical qualifications and patient satisfaction to how easy it is to schedule an appointment. Just as the Port Jefferson Ferry has been reliably connecting people since 1883, we want to connect you with dental care you can trust.

Some of the dentists listed below may pay for a sponsored listing or agree to put a DenScore badge on their website in order to be recognized, but they are held to the same strict quality control guidelines as every other provider on this list. Whether you choose a dentist from this list or not, we always recommend doing your own research beforehand. For more information, please refer to our Terms of Service.

Rank Dental Office Address Phone Number Website
1 Smile Shack 3 Medical Dr d, Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776 631-928-7500 https://www.smileshack.com/
2 Smile Makers 14 N Country Rd, Port Jefferson, NY 11777 631-473-0052 http://www.lismilemakers.com/
3 Port Jefferson Dental Group 602 Main St, Port Jefferson, NY 11777 631-473-1511 http://www.portjeffdental.com/
4 Distinctive Dentistry of Long Island 140 Terryville Rd, Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776 631-473-3094 http://www.distinctivedentistryoflongisland.com/
5 e.s.i. Healthy Dentistry 42 Terry Rd, Smithtown, NY 11787 631-979-7991 http://www.esihealthydentistry.com/
6 Dental365 – Stony Brook 1113 NY-25A Bldg. #3, Suites G, Stony Brook, NY 11790 631-689-1800 https://www.godental365.com/location/dentist-stony-brook
7 Erica R. Kaplan, DDS, DABP 9 Roosevelt Ave, Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776 631-476-1700 http://www.drericakaplan.com/
8 Total Family Dentistry Of St James 331 1st Ave, St James, NY 11780 631-584-5523 http://totalfamilydentistry.com/
9 PreserveYourTeeth – Dentistry Alice Urbankova DDS, PhD – East Setauket, Long Island 196 N Belle Mead Rd #6, Setauket- East Setauket, NY 11733 631-246-8080 http://preserveyourteeth.com/
10 Lynn A. Travis, DDS 5225 Nesconset Hwy Building 6, Unit 33, Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776 631-473-8700 https://lynntravisdds.com/
11 Port Jefferson Smiles 12 Roosevelt Ave, Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776 631-928-1300 http://www.portjeffersonsmiles.com/
12 Gentle Dental – Port Jefferson – A Dental365 Company 656 Main St, Port Jefferson, NY 11777 631-928-9898 https://www.godental365.com/location/dentist-port-jefferson
13 Drs. Witrock and Axelrod LLP 5225 Nesconset Hwy #40, Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776 631-928-2830 http://www.drswitrockandaxelrod.com/
14 Stony Brook General & Cosmetic Dentistry, Dr. Snehal Sheth D.D.S Medical Park, 2500 Nesconset Hwy bldg 12 d, Stony Brook, NY 11790 631-689-3226 http://www.sbcosmeticdentistry.com/
15 Stony Brook Family & Laser Dentistry 207 Hallock Rd # 5, Stony Brook, NY 11790 631-906-2227 http://laserdentistry-li.com/
16 N.J. Nicastro Dental – A Dental365 Company 5225 Nesconset Hwy Suite 52, Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776 631-928-2020 https://www.godental365.com/location/dentist-port-jefferson-station
17 Port Jefferson Dental PC 488 Terryville Rd, Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776 631-473-5300 http://www.portjeffersondental.com/
18 Dentistry Unlimited 1212 N Country Rd #4A, Stony Brook, NY 11790 631-360-1544 https://www.dentistryunlimitedofstjames.net/
19 Perrotta Anthony J DDS 1 Medical Dr suite a, Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776 631-689-6969 https://juliaperrotta10.wixsite.com/anthonyjperrottadds
20 Aspen Dental – Port Jefferson Station, NY 4900 Nesconset Hwy, Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776 631-403-3216 https://www.aspendental.com/dentist/ny/port-jefferson-stati/4900-a-nesconset-hwy
21 Concerned Dental Care of Port Jefferson 492 Old Town Rd, Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776 631-928-1018 https://concerneddentalcare.com/locations/port-jefferson/
22 LI Dental Care at Setauket 45 NY-25A #1, Setauket- East Setauket, NY 11733 631-905-6061 http://www.setauketdental.com/
23 Tim Yin DDS 100-12 S Jersey Ave, Setauket- East Setauket, NY 11733 631-751-9565 http://www.setauketdentist.com/
24 Sara Grace D.D.S. 46 NY-25A #7, Setauket- East Setauket, NY 11733 631-473-4400 http://saragracedentistry.com/
25 Anthony Mastronardi, DMD, PC 367 Old Town Rd, Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776 631-473-8292 https://www.mastronardidental.com/
26 Mt Sinai Family Dental 5505 Nesconset Hwy, Mt Sinai, NY 11766 631-331-8989 https://www.mtsinaidental.com/
27 Smthhaven Dentistry; Dr. Thomas R Douglas DDS 2233 Nesconset-Port Jefferson Hwy, Lake Grove, NY 11755 631-585-3130 http://www.smithhavendentistry.com/
28 Dos Santos Virginia B DDS 3 Roosevelt Ave, Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776 631-928-7200 http://www.dossantosdentalli.com/meet-the-doctors
29 Progressive Dental Care of Suffolk 5507 Nesconset Hwy, Mt Sinai, NY 11766 631-473-4477 http://www.mtsinaidentist.com/
30 Setauket Family Dentistry 175 Main St #11, Setauket- East Setauket, NY 11733 631-751-2255 http://www.setauketfamilydentistry.com/

*sponsored listing

Understanding Dental Insurance Coverage in Port Jefferson, NY

Choosing the right dental insurance can definitely lighten the financial load of dental care. If you qualify for Medicaid, your children can receive free dental care, though adult coverage is more limited. For our senior neighbors, while traditional Medicare doesn’t cover dental work, many Medicare Advantage plans offer excellent dental benefits. Like finding a good parking spot near Main Street on a busy summer weekend, navigating insurance options takes some patience – but we’re here to help you understand your choices.

Finding Affordable Dentists Near Me in Port Jefferson

The best way to keep dental costs down is prevention – just like how our local boats need regular maintenance to stay seaworthy. Maintain good oral hygiene, watch your sugar intake, and avoid tobacco products. If you have insurance, staying with an in-network dentist usually saves money. No insurance? Don’t worry! Many dental offices offer membership plans that make care more affordable. Prices can vary significantly between practices, so we recommend calling a few offices to compare costs for specific procedures when paying cash. A little research can go a long way in finding care that fits your budget.

How do I know if I’m getting the right dental treatment?

Whether you have a tooth that needs to be fixed, a gum problem, or concerns about your smile, there are likely multiple ways to treat your condition. DenScore’s free online dental tool will provide you with information so you can ask your dentist the right questions and get the high-quality dental care you deserve.

Key Takeaways

  • Port Jefferson offers numerous highly-rated dental practices for comprehensive oral care
  • DenScore’s rating system helps identify the best dentists near you based on multiple factors
  • Various insurance options and payment plans make dental care more accessible
  • Preventive care and regular maintenance help reduce long-term dental costs
  • Local dental offices provide flexible payment options for patients without insurance