Best Dentists in Bay Shore, NY (2025): Your Complete Guide to Top-Rated Dental Care

Living in a bustling community like Bay Shore, NY means you have plenty of dentists to choose from – which can feel both exciting and overwhelming! Whether you’re new to the area or just looking for a change, we at DenScore are here to help you find the perfect dentist for your needs, just as easily as catching the ferry to Fire Island on a summer afternoon.

How DenScore Identifies the Best Dentists Near You in Bay Shore

We take the guesswork out of finding a great dentist by evaluating factors that really matter to patients. Think of us as your dental matchmakers! We look at clinical qualifications, patient satisfaction, and how easy it is to get an appointment. Just like how Main Street has transformed into a vibrant destination with carefully selected businesses, we’ve created a thoughtfully curated list of dental professionals who meet our rigorous standards.

Some of the dentists listed below may pay for a sponsored listing or agree to put a DenScore badge on their website in order to be recognized, but they are held to the same strict quality control guidelines as every other provider on this list. Whether you choose a dentist from this list or not, we always recommend doing your own research beforehand. For more information, please refer to our Terms of Service.

Rank Dental Office Address Phone Number Website
1 Advanced Dental Care 375 E Main St Suite 19, Bay Shore, NY 11706 631-665-0165 https://www.advanceddentalcare.net/
2 Fran Eichler DDS – General & Family Dentistry 1 Annette Ave, Smithtown, NY 11787 631-253-8368 https://frantasticsmiles.com/
3 Kathleen M. Frost, DDS, PC 150 Islip Ave Suite #11, Islip, NY 11751 631-581-3100 https://www.frostperiodontics.com/
4 Islip Dental Associates 375 Main St, Islip, NY 11751 631-581-2038 http://www.myislipdentist.com/
5 Don A. Pantino, D.D.S. 309 Main St, Islip, NY 11751 631-623-0249 http://www.donpantinodds.com/
6 Sayville Family Dentistry 207 W Main St, Sayville, NY 11782 631-589-0672 http://www.sayvillefamilydentistry.com/
7 Raymond Mascolo DDS 242 Main St, Islip, NY 11751 631-224-7660 http://www.drmascolo.com/
8 Babylon Dental Care 785 Montauk Hwy, West Babylon, NY 11704 631-983-6665 https://www.babylondentalcare.com/
9 Hills Park Dental 2053 Deer Pk Ave, Deer Park, NY 11729 631-254-6596 https://www.hillsparkdental.com/
10 The Center for Cosmetic Dentistry 373 NY-111, Smithtown, NY 11787 631-265-2700 https://www.keepsmilingli.com/
11 Blossom Dental 796 Deer Pk Rd # 4, North Babylon, NY 11703 631-598-3331 https://www.blossomdentalny.com/
12 Terrace Dental Associates 859 Connetquot Ave Ste. 1, Islip Terrace, NY 11752 631-277-3100 http://terracedentalassociates.com/
13 The Smilist Dental East Islip 228 E Main St, East Islip, NY 11730 631-581-8600 https://thesmilist.com/east-islip-dentist/
14 LK Dental Group 2050 Deer Pk Ave, Deer Park, NY 11729 631-586-2600 https://www.lkdentalgroup.com/
15 Raphaelson Dental Associates Corner of, 450 Grand Blvd, W 2nd St, Deer Park, NY 11729 631-667-4080 http://www.raphaelsondds.com/
16 ProHEALTH Dental 11 Bay Shore Rd, Bay Shore, NY 11706 631-305-4883 https://www.phdental.com/locations/prohealth-dental/bay-shore-ny/
17 Face Lips Teeth 720 Montauk Hwy, West Islip, NY 11795 631-666-1392 http://facelipsteeth.com/
18 Henry I. Ferdman, DDS P.C. 496 W Main St, West Babylon, NY 11704 631-669-1878 http://babylondentist.com/
19 Grace Dental Smiles 102 NY-109, West Babylon, NY 11704 631-619-0010 https://www.gracedentalsmiles.com/
20 Dr. Harold Guerrero Dental Family Practice PC 1355 E 3rd Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706 631-910-4888 https://hgfamilydental.com/
21 Comfort Dental 456 Union Blvd, West Islip, NY 11795 631-422-1104 https://comfortdental.dtpcreative.com/
22 Gordon John DDS 111 Carleton Ave, Islip Terrace, NY 11752 631-581-3500 http://www.johngordondds.com/
23 Natalia Elson DDS PC 150 Islip Ave Suite#5, Islip, NY 11751 631-581-0216 http://www.doctorelson.com/
24 Bayshore Family Dental 1322 5th Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706 631-968-5995 https://bayshorefamilydental.com/
25 Great Expressions Dental Centers – Bayshore 1701 Sunrise Hwy Space C7, Bay Shore, NY 11706 631-666-1440 https://www.greatexpressions.com/dental-offices/dentist-in-bay-shore-new-york-sunrise-highway-space-no-c7/
26 Yavuz Sefik DDS 1117 Deer Pk Ave, North Babylon, NY 11703 631-595-2400 http://www.myadental.com/our-practice/meet-the-doctor/
27 Altmark Kidz Dentistry 77 Veterans Memorial Hwy #1, Commack, NY 11725 631-499-2100 https://www.altmarkkidzdentistry.com/
28 Harbor Bay Dental 53 Brentwood Rd, Bay Shore, NY 11706 631-666-0427 http://harborbaydental.com/specialized/
29 Dean Glasser, DDS 458 Old Country Rd, Melville, NY 11747 631-423-6767 http://www.drdeanglasser.com/
30 COMPREHENSIVE DENTISTRY PC 425 Broadhollow Rd #118, Melville, NY 11747 631-752-2929 http://www.fainabramdds.com/

*sponsored listing

Understanding Dental Insurance Coverage in Bay Shore, NY

Absolutely! Choosing the right dental insurance can make quality care as accessible as a stroll down Bay Shore’s beautiful waterfront. For families, Medicaid provides free dental care for children, though adult coverage is more limited. If you’re a senior, while traditional Medicare doesn’t cover dental care, many Medicare Advantage plans offer excellent coverage that can help manage the cost of dental procedures.

Tips for Affordable Dental Care in Bay Shore

Just like the Bay Shore Beautification Society transformed an empty lot into something beautiful, you can transform your dental health with some smart preventive care! Regular brushing, flossing, and limiting sugary treats will keep your smile healthy and your wallet happier. Staying with an in-network dentist usually saves money. No insurance? Don’t worry! Many dental offices offer membership plans that make care more affordable. And just like you might compare prices at different shops on Main Street, it’s worth calling a few dental offices to compare costs for specific procedures when paying cash.

How do I know if I’m getting the right dental treatment?

Whether you have a tooth that needs to be fixed, a gum problem, or concerns about your smile, there are likely multiple ways to treat your condition. DenScore’s free online dental tool will provide you with information so you can ask your dentist the right questions and get the high-quality dental care you deserve.

Key Takeaways

  • DenScore evaluates top-rated dental care providers in Bay Shore based on clinical excellence and patient satisfaction
  • Multiple insurance options are available to make dental care more affordable
  • Preventive care and in-network providers help reduce dental costs
  • Many local dentists offer flexible payment plans and membership options
  • Bay Shore offers numerous highly-qualified dental professionals to choose from